Gas Fireplace Insert for an Existing Fireplace: What Fits

Gas fireplace inserts

Gas Fireplace Insert for an Existing Fireplace: What Fits

An insert's size is a model name, not a measurement. How to measure your firebox, what the install requires (liner, hearth) and which inserts fit.

A gas fireplace insert fits your existing fireplace when the firebox meets the insert's minimum opening for front width, rear width, height and depth, and when the chimney can take the liner the insert requires. The size in the model name won't tell you whether it fits: some inserts need more front width than their name, some less. Measure four things, compare them with the insert's minimum opening, and you will know before you order.

Quick answer

An insert fits when all four of these hold:

  • The firebox clears the insert's minimum opening. Measure front width, rear width, height and depth at the narrowest points. The name is no guide: the Empire Rushmore 30 needs 31-1/4 inches across the front, the Loft 32 only 30-1/2.
  • The chimney can take a liner. The direct vent inserts in our table need an approved flue liner run up the chimney, an 8-inch minimum flue and at least 10 feet of vertical rise.
  • The hearth stays. The original hearth remains. Only if it was damaged or removed does a new one go in: non-combustible, the width of the fireplace and at least 16 inches out in front.
  • It is a working wood-burning fireplace. Masonry or factory-built, cleaned and inspected before the insert goes in.

Start with our gas fireplace inserts: every product page links the install manual with the minimum opening.

Will a gas fireplace insert work in your existing fireplace?

It will if you have a working wood-burning fireplace: a brick or stone masonry fireplace, or a listed factory-built one with a metal firebox. If yours already has a sealed gas fireplace behind glass, an insert is the wrong product; you are replacing the fireplace.

The fireplace and its chimney must be cleaned and inspected first, to make sure they are in good working order. A chimney sweep or inspector does that, before you measure anything.

Masonry or factory-built: how to tell

A masonry fireplace is built on site from brick, block or stone, with mortar joints inside the firebox and a masonry chimney above. A factory-built (zero-clearance) fireplace is a metal box set into a framed wall, usually with refractory panels lining the firebox and a round metal chimney pipe.

For a quick check, shine a flashlight up through the damper. A round metal pipe usually means factory-built; a square or rectangular clay or brick flue usually means masonry. Both take an insert. They differ in what may be removed to make room.

When a chimney can't be used

Two things rule out a chimney before size matters. The insert's vent must never connect to a chimney that also serves another solid-fuel or gas appliance, such as a furnace flue in the same stack. And the vent cap has to sit in open air, never under a cap shared with other flues.

One more condition: once converted, the fireplace is gas-only. It can't burn wood again unless all original parts go back in and the local authority approves it.

How to measure for a gas fireplace insert

Measure four things in the firebox, each at its narrowest point: front width, rear width, height and depth. The insert has to clear the tightest spot. Then measure the hearth, the flue and the chimney height.

One "width x height" number won't settle it, because many fireboxes taper: the back wall is narrower than the front. Every Empire insert has a minimum for all four.

Front and top view of a tapered firebox showing front width, rear width, height, depth and hearth in front
Four firebox measurements plus the hearth, each at the narrowest point.

The four firebox measurements

Front width. Across the opening, just inside the face. Brick openings are rarely square, so check top and bottom.

Rear width. Across the back wall at floor level. On a tapered firebox, this number often decides the fit.

Height. From the firebox floor to the lowest point at the top of the opening, often the lintel or a low damper frame.

Depth. From the front edge of the opening to the back wall. If the back slopes forward, measure low and high and keep the smaller number. Some inserts, like the Rushmore, let you subtract your surround's depth; otherwise use the listed depth (see the note under the table).

Take out glass doors, screens and log grates before you measure. In a factory-built fireplace, they may come out to reach the minimum opening. In a masonry firebox they come off too, but ask your installer before anything else is removed.

Three more numbers to bring

  • Hearth depth. How far the non-combustible hearth extends in front of the opening, and whether it runs the full width.
  • Flue size. The smallest inside dimension of the chimney flue. The direct vent inserts in the table below need at least 8 inches.
  • Chimney height. From the firebox to the chimney top. The same inserts need at least 10 feet of vertical vent.

Note any ledge, lip or trim that sticks out around the opening and show it to your installer, since the surround covers that area.

Why a 30-inch insert needs more than 30 inches

The number in an insert's name is a model name. The opening it needs is its minimum fireplace opening, and the two rarely agree. What size gas fireplace insert do you need? One whose minimum opening fits inside all four of your measurements.

The Empire Rushmore 30 is the clearest case. Its name says 30, yet it needs 31-1/4 inches across the front, so a firebox exactly 30 inches wide is too narrow for it. The table below lists its other three minimums.

Empire Rushmore 30 insert minimum opening: front 31-1/4 in, rear 22 in, height 19-1/2 in, depth 18 in
A Rushmore 30 needs more than 30 inches of front width.

The gap runs both ways: some inserts need more front width than their name, some less. The Rushmore 30 needs 31-1/4 inches; the Loft 32, though 32-1/4 inches wide itself, needs only a 30-1/2-inch front opening because its face sits in front of the fireplace. Here is the minimum opening for six Empire inserts.

Insert (model name) Width, front / rear Height Depth
Rushmore 30 31-1/4" / 22" 19-1/2" 18"*
Rushmore 35 35-1/4" / 25-3/4" 24-1/2" 19"*
Innsbrook DV 40 28-1/4" / 17-1/4" 18-1/2" 14-7/8"**
Innsbrook DV 43 31-1/4" / 19" 21-1/2" 16-5/8"
Innsbrook DV 46 34-1/4" / 22" 23-1/2" 16-5/8"
Loft 32 (vent-free) 30-1/2" / 19" 22-3/8" 15"
Other brands' minimum openings are on each product page.

On the Rushmore rows (*), subtract the depth of the surround you choose. The Innsbrook DV 40 (**) needs 14-7/8 inches with a 1-inch-deep surround, or 13-5/8 inches with a 2-1/4-inch one.

Rear width does the sorting. The Rushmore 30 and the Innsbrook DV 43 need the same 31-1/4-inch front width, but the Rushmore needs 3 more inches across the back: 22 against 19. A tapered masonry firebox with a narrow back wall can take the Innsbrook DV 43 and still reject the Rushmore 30.

Majestic inserts have the same kind of minimum opening. The Majestic Ruby 30 Direct Vent Gas Fireplace Insert's figures assume a standard 3/4-inch-deep surround, and a custom surround is offered for smaller openings.

Fit check: every insert page links its install manual; check the minimum opening against your four measurements before you order.

Empire Rushmore 30 direct vent gas fireplace insert, front view with log set and flames behind a black surround

Direct vent insert · 30 inch

Empire Rushmore 30" Clean Face Direct Vent Fireplace Insert

  • Needs 31-1/4" front, 22" rear, 19-1/2" high, 18" deep
  • Dual burner, multi-function remote with thermostat
View product
Empire Innsbrook direct vent insert with logs and brick-look liner, installed in a red brick fireplace under a black mantel

Direct vent insert · 43 inch

Empire Innsbrook 43" Medium Direct-Vent Clean Face Gas Fireplace Insert

  • Needs 31-1/4" front, 19" rear, 21-1/2" high, 16-5/8" deep
  • Factory-installed blower, millivolt or intermittent pilot
View product
Empire Loft 32 vent-free gas fireplace insert, front view with a low row of flames behind a black mesh screen and surround

Vent-free insert · 32 inch

Empire Loft 32" Medium Vent-Free Gas Fireplace Insert (28,000 BTU)

  • Needs 30-1/2" front, 19" rear, 22-3/8" high, 15" deep
  • Not for bedrooms or bathrooms; optional blower
View product

What you can change, and what you can't

If the firebox is a little small, some parts may come out. In a factory-built fireplace, the firebrick and accessories may be removed, but the metal box may not be cut. The hearth stays, and a surround is required.

Removing parts to reach the minimum opening

In a factory-built fireplace, the firebrick (refractory panels), glass doors, screen rails, screen mesh and log grates may come out to enlarge the opening. Interior baffles, smoke shields and shelves may go too, if they're attached with mechanical fasteners.

The limits are just as clear. Cutting the sheet metal parts of an existing fireplace is prohibited unless the manual says otherwise, and the firebox side walls and top may not be altered, apart from removable baffles and dampers. If a factory-built firebox is an inch short, pick a smaller insert.

In a masonry firebox, ask your installer and local building official before any lining brick comes out.

The hearth stays

Empire's direct vent inserts need no extra hearth extension, but the original hearth must remain. If it was damaged or removed, a new one goes in: non-combustible material (brick, tile, slate or marble) across the width of the fireplace and at least 16 inches out in front. Wood flooring, vinyl and carpet can't sit directly in front of the insert.

The Loft vent-free insert needs no hearth extension either, but vinyl, carpet and wood-based flooring must stay at least 16 inches from its face.

A surround is required, and on some inserts it lowers the depth you need

Every insert here needs a surround, the panel that closes the gap between the insert and the old opening. The Rushmore takes only manufacturer-supplied surrounds, with the mantel above the surround. The Empire Rushmore Decorative Surround for 30" Fireplace Inserts comes in several sizes, most of them 1 inch deep, plus two flush versions. That inch counts toward the depth: with a 1-inch surround, the Rushmore 30's 18-inch requirement drops to 17 inches.

The damper

A direct vent insert needs the damper removed or locked fully open. In a masonry chimney it may have to come out entirely so the flexible vent pipes fit through. A narrow damper throat can block the pipes, so have your installer check it at the site visit.

Chimney liners and venting for a direct vent insert

A direct vent gas fireplace insert is sealed: it pulls outside air in and pushes exhaust out through flexible pipes run up your existing chimney, which together form the liner.

Every direct vent insert in the table requires an approved flue liner, a flue of at least 8 inches, vertical venting only (no horizontal termination) and at least 10 feet of rise. The maximum rise is 40 feet for the Rushmore and 35 feet for the Innsbrook DV.

Two pipes or one pipe inside another

Both Empire lines run two separate flexible pipes up the chimney, one for combustion air and one for exhaust; installers call this co-linear. The Rushmore uses a 3-inch pipe for incoming air and a 4-inch pipe for exhaust, the Innsbrook DV 3-inch pipe for both. Co-axial means one pipe inside another. The Innsbrook DV's round termination kit includes a co-axial adapter for mounting the cap on a factory-built fireplace's existing round chimney pipe.

The insert makes the choice for you: only its listed vent parts are approved.

The "liner" on the Rushmore parts list is not the chimney liner

Among the Rushmore's accessories is the "DVCT30 LINER (REQUIRED)." That liner is the set of interior firebox panels behind the flame, in black glass, rustic brick, cottage brick, traditional stone or Old World stone finishes. The chimney vent pipes are listed separately.

The Rushmore needs both. The panel set is required, and the Rushmore must not run with liner panels removed or damaged. We sell those panels as the Empire Liner Accessory for 30"/35" Rushmore Fireplaces; the chimney vent kit is a separate order. On the Innsbrook DV, the brick and porcelain "liners" are decorative options and play no part in venting either.

Ventless gas fireplace inserts

A vent-free insert such as the Loft 32 has no vent, so no liner goes up the flue. It burns room air and releases its combustion products into the room, so room-size rules replace chimney rules.

The Loft 32 can't go in a bedroom or bathroom, and the room needs enough volume for its input or added ventilation openings. Wood can never be burned in a fireplace that holds a vent-free heater. Some areas restrict vent-free appliances, so read our vent-free sales policy before you choose one. Our guide to direct vent vs vent-free vs B-vent compares the three in depth.

Gas fireplace inserts with a blower

A blower pushes warm air from around the firebox into the room. Some inserts ship with one and others offer it as an option; either way, plan a 120-volt outlet.

Both direct vent inserts above come with a factory-installed blower. The Innsbrook DV adds a temperature-activated fan control and a speed knob. On the Rushmore the blower is part of the insert, not a separate kit, and it runs on the supplied 120-volt cord. The Loft 32 takes an optional variable-speed blower, and its millivolt version runs the burner without electricity. The Majestic Ruby 30 has an integrated fan.

Power comes from a junction box inside the old firebox or the supplied cord routed to a nearby outlet; near a sink, the circuit needs GFCI protection. An electrician handles the wiring.

What a gas insert install adds

Gas fireplace insert cost covers more than the insert. Plan for these items on top of it:

  • Vent kit and liner pipes. Sized to your chimney height. The Rushmore's listed vertical kit includes the cap, flashing, 35 feet of each pipe and clamps. Some chimney tops also need locally made flashing.
  • Surround. Required, sold separately, in the size that covers your opening.
  • Model-specific parts. The Rushmore also needs its firebox liner panels and a log set, both sold separately.
  • Gas line to the firebox. Run by a qualified installer from your gas supply to the insert's shut-off valve.
  • Electrical. An outlet or junction box for the blower or controls.
  • Chimney cleaning and inspection. Required before the insert goes in, plus any masonry or cap repairs the inspection finds.
  • Hearth work. Only if the original hearth is damaged or was removed; the replacement has to meet the hearth rule above.

Choose the fuel when you order. Inserts come in a natural gas or a propane version; the Rushmore 30 and Innsbrook DV 43 pages list both. The Loft vent-free is not field-convertible, so get the fuel right the first time.

A gas insert is installed and serviced by a qualified installer, service agency or gas supplier, and on Empire inserts the warranty depends on it. Ask for a written quote that names each item.

Gas insert vs gas logs

An insert is a sealed appliance built to heat the room; gas logs keep the open-fireplace look. If you mostly want flames, a log set is simpler. If you want heat, choose an insert.

Option Best for Main plus Main minus
Direct vent gas insert Heating the room Sealed, uses outside air Liner, surround, install work
Vented gas logs The open-fire look Simplest change Decorative, not a heater
Vent-free gas logs Heat without a vent No liner Room-size and local limits
Electric insert No gas, no chimney work Plugs into an outlet Less heat, no real flame

Vented log sets are certified as decorative appliances. They burn in the open firebox and vent through the existing chimney, so choose them for the look rather than for heat. Browse both types in our gas log sets.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Ordering by the name. A 30-inch model can need a 31-1/4-inch opening.
  • Measuring only the front. Rear width and depth can rule out an insert that clears the front.
  • Ignoring the surround. It is required, and on some inserts its depth changes the firebox depth needed.
  • Sharing a flue. A chimney that already vents a furnace can't take the insert's vent.

Common questions

Can I install a gas insert myself?

No. Gas inserts are installed by a qualified installer, service agency or gas supplier, and on Empire inserts a non-qualified install voids the warranty. Gas piping and venting also fall under local code, usually with a permit.

My chimney is short. Can I still use a direct vent insert?

Not one from our table if the rise is under 10 feet. Those inserts need at least 10 feet of vertical vent, measured from the insert's collars to the top of the vent pipe. For any other insert, the minimum rise varies by model; ask us before you order.

Nothing seems small enough for my opening. What now?

Re-check rear width first; it is often the real limit. In the table, the Innsbrook DV 40 needs the least front width and height. The Empire Loft 29" Small Vent-Free insert needs 27-1/2 inches across the front and 19-3/8 inches of height. If those don't fit, an electric insert is often the practical answer.

How many BTUs does my insert need?

It depends on room size, climate and insulation. Each product page lists the insert's maximum and minimum input; ask us if you're between sizes.

This guide was researched and drafted with AI assistance, checked line by line against manufacturer specifications and our catalog, and approved by the HearthDepot Hearth Team. Read how we write our guides.

Search

Call 888-398-1887Mon–Sat 8am–8pm ET
>