Propane vs Natural Gas Fireplace: Which Can Your House Use?

Gas fireplace buying guide

Propane vs Natural Gas Fireplace: Which Can Your House Use?

Your gas line, tank rules and HOA usually decide. What changes on the unit, conversion kits and fuel use per hour.

If your home has natural gas service, the fireplace runs on natural gas; if it doesn't, propane from a tank on the property is the usual answer, as long as your lot, building and HOA allow a tank. For most buyers, the address settles the propane vs natural gas fireplace question. Most fireplace models are made in both versions, and the two differ less than many comparisons suggest.

Quick answer

  • Gas service at the house: buy the natural gas version. No tank, no deliveries, and over the past decade about half the cost of propane for the same heat, or less.
  • No gas service: propane, if a tank is allowed where you live. Condo rules, HOA documents and tank distances on a small lot can rule it out.
  • No gas and no tank: electric is the honest answer.
  • Both fuels work indoors in a vented fireplace. The fuel changes the valve and orifices; the venting stays the same.
  • On the models we checked, the propane version's maximum BTU rating is the same or a little lower, never higher.
  • Start with our gas fireplaces. Pages that offer both fuels have a Fuel Type selector; some models are listed in natural gas only, so check the fuel on the page before you order.

Most buyers don't choose between propane and natural gas: the house does

If a gas line already reaches the house, natural gas is the simplest fuel for a fireplace: the supply is there and nobody has to deliver it. Without one, it comes down to whether your property can have a propane tank. Only a few situations leave you a real choice.

Check in this order. A natural gas meter on the house means a branch line and the natural gas version. No meter? Ask whether your building, HOA and lot can take a propane tank; if not, look at electric.

Decision path: gas service leads to natural gas; no service but a tank allowed leads to propane; otherwise electric.
Your address usually picks the fuel before you pick the fireplace.

Watch the side branch: an existing propane tank, or a gas main on your street that never reached the house, leaves both fuels workable. First, the cases where your home takes one off the table.

When your home rules out one fuel

Condos and many HOAs restrict or ban propane tanks, and code-required distances from a tank to windows, doors and property lines can make a small lot unworkable. In either situation, natural gas or electric is your realistic option. Your local fire or building office and your HOA documents decide.

Condos and apartments. Many condo buildings won't allow a tank on a balcony or in a shared yard, so a condo without gas service often ends up electric. Check the condo declaration before you price any gas unit.

HOAs. An association's covenants can limit tank size, require burial or screening, or prohibit tanks outright. Ask the board for the written rule.

Small lots. Code sets minimum distances from a tank to the house, its openings and the property line. The distance grows with tank size and changes for buried tanks, and towns can add stricter rules. On a narrow city lot, the propane supplier may find no legal spot.

Rural homes and cabins. Propane is usually the only gas option here, and a tank is routine. In our own recent orders, vent-free gas appliances have been bought as propane units, which fits homes with no gas line.

Manufactured homes. The fireplace has to be listed for them. The Majestic Quartz, for example, is approved for manufactured-home installation; check your model's install manual.

When neither fuel fits, our electric fireplaces need no gas, no tank and no vent, only power.

When you actually get a choice

You get a real choice in three cases: the home already has a propane tank, the street has a gas main but the house isn't connected, or you're building new. In each, weigh the one-time cost of getting fuel to the house against what each fuel costs to burn.

You already have a propane tank. Adding a fireplace to an existing propane system is often the least work: your supplier confirms the tank and regulator can carry another appliance, and your installer runs the line.

Gas at the street, not at the house. The gas company may charge to extend the service line and set a meter. Set that written quote beside the cost of a propane tank, its installation and deliveries. A natural gas hookup can also serve a future furnace, range or dryer, which changes the math.

New construction. Decide the fuel with your builder before framing, since the gas line, meter or tank pad goes in early.

Outdoor fireplaces. A patio unit is its own fuel decision, even in a natural gas home, because it needs a line run outside or a tank nearby. The Majestic Meridian is approved in both natural gas and propane for covered patios and outdoor rooms.

Once both are possible, the fuels compare like this:

What matters Natural gas Propane
Supply at the house Utility line and meter Tank on the property
Deliveries None Refills by your supplier
Cost per unit of heat Lower, past decade 1.8 to 2.6×, past decade
Where it works Where service exists Wherever a tank is allowed
Main hassle Hookup if not connected Tank rules and refills

If you have gas service, there's rarely a reason to add a propane tank just for a fireplace. Whichever fuel wins, the fireplace itself changes very little.

Propane vs natural gas fireplace: same model, two fuels

You order a fireplace as the natural gas version or the propane version. Both share the firebox, glass and venting; the gas valve setup, burner orifices and rating plate differ, and the propane version usually carries a slightly lower maximum input rating. Here is the maximum input on each fuel for six fireplaces we sell.

Fireplace Natural gas, BTU/hr Propane, BTU/hr Propane vs gas
Superior DRL2035 35" 15,000 14,000 1,000 lower
Superior DRL2055 55" 23,000 21,000 2,000 lower
Majestic Quartz 36" 24,000 20,500 3,500 lower
Empire Boulevard 36" DV 29,000 28,000 1,000 lower
Empire Boulevard 60" DV 46,000 42,500 3,500 lower
Superior BRT4336 36" B-vent 40,000 40,000 Same
Maximum input at sea level to 2,000 ft.

So does propane burn hotter? Per cubic foot, propane carries more energy than natural gas, which is where the idea comes from. A fireplace, though, meters its gas through orifices sized for each fuel, and the rated input sets the heat. On every model above, propane's maximum input is rated the same or a little lower. Minimum input can run the other way: the Boulevard 36" is rated 19,000 BTU/hr minimum on natural gas and 22,000 on propane.

What changes between the two versions:

  • The orifice. Propane runs through a much smaller burner orifice: on the DRL2055, a #55 drill size versus #47 for natural gas.
  • Supply pressure. The Superior DRL calls for 5 to 10.5 inches of water column on natural gas and 11 to 13 on propane, so propane runs at higher pressure.
  • The model number. The last letter usually tells you the fuel: DRL2055TEN is natural gas and DRL2055TEP is the LP (propane) version; Majestic uses QUARTZ36IFTN and QUARTZ36IFTL.
  • Altitude. Above 2,000 ft some models need a smaller orifice and a lower rating; your model's install manual has the high-altitude figures.

A propane fireplace insert works the same way. The Majestic Ruby 30" Direct Vent Gas Fireplace Insert, for example, comes in both fuels; order it in yours.

Superior DRL2055 linear direct vent gas fireplace with driftwood-style logs, front view

Linear direct vent · 55 inch

Superior DRL2000 55" Linear Direct Vent Gas Fireplace (DRL2055)

  • Max input 23,000 BTU/hr natural gas, 21,000 propane
  • Electronic ignition with battery backup
View product
Majestic Quartz 36 direct vent gas fireplace with log set, installed in a white mantel surround in a living room

Direct vent · 36 inch

Majestic Quartz 36" Direct Vent Gas Fireplace

  • Max input 24,000 BTU/hr natural gas, 20,500 propane
  • Certified for bedroom installation
View product
Empire Boulevard 36 linear direct vent gas fireplace installed in a wood-paneled wall below a TV in a living room

Linear direct vent · 36 inch

Empire Boulevard 36" Direct Vent Linear Contemporary Gas Fireplace

  • Max input 29,000 BTU/hr natural gas, 28,000 propane
  • Multifunction remote included
View product

The Superior BRT4336/BRT4536 36" B-Vent Gas Fireplace is the exception in the table: Superior rates it at 40,000 BTU/hr on both fuels.

Pages that offer both fuels have a Fuel Type selector, and some models are listed in natural gas only. Settle the fuel, check it on the page before ordering, and browse our direct vent gas fireplaces.

Converting later: kits and who installs them

If your fuel supply changes later, many gas fireplaces can be converted between natural gas and propane, but only with the manufacturer's kit for that exact model, installed by a qualified technician. No kit from the manufacturer means the fireplace stays on the fuel it shipped with.

A gas fireplace is not convertible to another gas unless a certified kit is used, and the conversion is made by a qualified service technician or agency with the maker's specified parts. On Superior units, the job isn't complete until that agency checks the converted fireplace in operation.

Kits are specific to size and direction. The Empire Boulevard has one kit for natural gas to propane and another for propane to natural gas on each size. Our Superior Conversion Kits for DRL3500 Series Linear Gas Fireplaces work the same way: one version per size and direction, each with the orifices, regulator parts and a new label for the rating plate. Those kits fit the DRL3535, DRL3545 and DRL3555 only; the DRL2000 models in the table, including the DRL2055, take their own DRL2000 kits.

Check one detail before you count on converting: BRT4300 conversion kits are listed for the electronic-ignition versions, so on another ignition type, confirm a kit exists first.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Ordering the natural gas version "to convert later" when you know you're on propane. Order the right fuel and skip the kit and the service call.
  • Treating conversion as a jet swap. The kits change regulator parts and labeling too.
  • Running an indoor fireplace off a grill cylinder (see the tank section below).

Fuel use and running cost per hour

A fireplace burns fuel at its BTU input rate, so its hourly use comes straight off the rating plate. Divide BTU per hour by 100,000 for therms of natural gas, or by about 91,500 for gallons of propane, then multiply by the rate on your own bill.

Fuel-use and cost formula

Natural gas: BTU per hour ÷ 100,000 = therms per hour. Therms per hour × your rate per therm = cost per hour.

Propane: BTU per hour ÷ 91,500 = gallons per hour. Gallons per hour × your rate per gallon = cost per hour.

If your gas bill shows CCF, one CCF is about 1.04 therms.

Worked example, Superior DRL2055 on high. Run the formula on both versions and each burns about 0.23 unit of fuel an hour: a therm of natural gas or a gallon of propane. The table sets that beside what each fuel has cost in U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) data.

Fuel DRL2055 on high Fuel per hour Past-decade price range
Natural gas 23,000 BTU/hr About 0.23 therm About $0.97 to $1.49 per therm
Propane 21,000 BTU/hr About 0.23 gallon About $1.96 to $2.77 per gallon
EIA residential averages: natural gas by year, 2015 to 2025; propane by heating season, 2015-16 to 2025-26.

Your local rate can sit well outside those ranges, so use your bill.

Tank planning. One gallon of propane runs the DRL2055 on high for about 4.4 hours.

Which is cheaper. Natural gas, by a wide margin: for the same heat, propane cost about 1.8 to 2.6 times as much in each year of that EIA data. The propane version's slightly lower input narrows the per-hour gap a little without closing it.

The pilot. A standing pilot stays lit continuously, even when the fire is off, and adds fuel use between fires. Intermittent (electronic) ignition lights the pilot only when the fire is called for, so check your model's ignition type on its product page. We'll cover ignition and controls in a separate guide.

Propane tanks: size and the grill-cylinder question

Your propane supplier sizes the tank for every appliance it will feed, so the fireplace is one load among the furnace, water heater or range. An indoor fireplace runs from that fixed outdoor supply, piped in by your installer. A grill cylinder won't do: the Superior fireplaces here must not run from any tank under 100 lb.

Propane supply tanks belong outdoors, never inside any structure. A tank under 100 lb can lose pressure and starve the burner, causing sooting or severe delayed ignition, and on the Superior units damage from an undersized tank isn't covered by the warranty. A 20 lb grill cylinder is a fifth of that minimum.

Tank placement, leasing and delivery schedules belong to your installer and propane supplier. To estimate how long a tank lasts, multiply the gallons on hand by 91,500 and divide by your fireplace's BTU per hour.

Indoor propane fireplaces: venting sets the rules

A propane fireplace is as suitable indoors as a natural gas one, and the venting type sets the indoor-air rules. Direct vent, B-vent and vent-free fireplaces are all made in both fuels. A direct vent propane fireplace draws outside air and sends exhaust back outside through a sealed pipe, exactly like its natural gas twin.

Our guide to direct vent vs vent-free vs B-vent explains how each type vents and what it needs. Vent-free units are restricted in some states and cities; our vent-free sales policy lists where we can't ship them.

Common questions

Is propane cleaner-burning than natural gas?

Published comparisons contradict each other, and neither Majestic, Empire nor Superior ranks one fuel as cleaner. For indoor air, venting matters more than fuel: a sealed direct vent fireplace sends its exhaust outside on either one.

Can one house have both natural gas and propane?

Yes. Some homes run natural gas indoors and propane for an outbuilding, or the reverse. Each appliance runs only on the gas named on its rating plate, so your installer keeps the two systems separate.

I already have a propane tank for my furnace. Can the fireplace use it?

Usually, if the tank and regulator can carry the added load. Your propane supplier checks that, and your installer runs the branch line. Order the propane version so no conversion is needed.

Should I go electric instead?

If you have no gas service and can't place a tank, yes. Electric fireplaces need only household power, which suits most condos. You give up a real gas flame for that simplicity.

This guide was researched and drafted with AI assistance, checked line by line against manufacturer specifications and our catalog, and approved by the HearthDepot Hearth Team. Read how we write our guides.

Search

Call 888-398-1887Mon–Sat 8am–8pm ET
>