Gas Wall Furnace vs Vent-Free Heater: Which Fits Your Room?

Gas wall heaters

Gas Wall Furnace vs Vent-Free Heater: Which Fits Your Room?

Direct vent wall furnace vs vent-free heater: where each gets its air, which run in a power outage, how big the room must be, and Empire model codes.

A direct vent wall furnace pulls its air from outside and sends its exhaust back out through the wall, so it can heat your living space day after day; a vent-free heater burns room air and releases its exhaust and moisture into the room, so it is limited to supplemental heat in a room large enough for its Btu rating. That is the core of the direct vent wall furnace vs vent-free heater choice. Three questions settle the rest: how often you need heat, which wall you have, and how big the room is.

Quick answer

  • Heating a room or a small home every day: pick a vented wall furnace. Direct vent mounts on an outside wall; B-vent needs a vent pipe run up through the roof.
  • Occasional heat in one room: a vent-free heater works if the room has at least 50 cubic feet of volume per 1,000 Btu/h of input and vent-free heaters are allowed where you live.
  • Bedrooms and bathrooms: vent-free only up to 10,000 Btu/h in a bedroom, wall-mounted, and up to 6,000 Btu/h in a bathroom.
  • Power outages: standing-pilot models keep heating with the power out; fan-type furnaces need a 120-volt outlet.
  • Before you order: compare models in our Empire gas heaters collection. Every product page links the install manual.

Direct vent wall furnace vs vent-free heater: where the air comes from

The difference between a wall furnace and a vent-free heater is where the burner gets its air and where the exhaust goes. A direct vent furnace is sealed off from the room; a vent-free heater burns room air and leaves its exhaust there. There are three air paths:

  • Direct vent. An air inlet tube and a flue outlet tube share one 7 1/2-inch opening in the outside wall and end in a vent cap, so the flame burns outdoor air.
  • B-vent. The burner burns room air, and the exhaust rises through a Type B vent pipe to the roof.
  • Vent-free. No pipe at all. The heater uses air (oxygen) from the room it is installed in.
Three heater types: direct vent uses outside air and a wall vent, B-vent a roof flue, vent-free vents into the room
The air path is the real difference between the three types.

The air path decides what the room must supply: the vent-free and B-vent types burn room air, so they come with room-volume and fresh-air rules, while a direct vent furnace's rules are about the outside wall. For the same three paths on gas fireplaces, see our guide to direct vent vs vent-free vs B-vent.

The vented choices: direct vent, B-vent and room heaters

Vented gas wall heaters come in three installs: direct vent needs an outside wall, B-vent a route for its vent pipe up through the roof, and a vented room heater a lined chimney or a B-vent. Usually the right one is whichever your house already allows.

Type Air in, exhaust out Needs house power? Best fit
Direct vent furnace (DV) Outside air in, out through the wall No Daily heat on an outside wall
Fan-type direct vent (DVC) Outside air in, out through the wall Yes, 120 V Daily heat, warm air at floor level
B-vent furnace (GWT, FAW) Room air in, flue up to the roof GWT no, FAW yes Inside walls with a roof path
Vented room heater (RH) Room air in, flue to chimney or B-vent No A room with a usable chimney
Vent-free blue flame (BF) Room air in, exhaust stays in the room No Occasional heat for a whole room
Vent-free infrared (SR) Room air in, exhaust stays in the room No Occasional heat where you sit
Optional blowers need power on every type.

Before you order: each heater page links its install manual. Check the venting and power needs against your wall before you order.

Direct vent wall furnaces (DV and DVC)

A direct vent wall furnace hangs on, or recesses into, an outside wall, so wall depth matters. The DV models (DV-25, DV-35, DV-210 and DV-215) fit walls 4 1/2 to 13 inches deep, or up to 19 with an extension kit. The fan-type DVC-35 fits walls 3/4 inch to 10 inches deep.

Inside the room, the DV-25 and DV-35 also need a clear stretch of wall 28 inches high by 49 inches wide.

Outside, the vent cap needs space from any window, door or other opening, and the distance grows with the unit's input:

  • 10,000 Btu/h or less (the DV-210): at least 6 inches.
  • Up to 50,000 Btu/h: at least 9 inches.
  • Larger units, such as the DVC-55: at least 12 inches.

The cap also sits at least 12 inches above the ground. On vinyl siding, a vent kit keeps the cap off the vinyl.

Empire builds each direct vent furnace for one gas, so order the natural gas or propane version.

Beige wall-mounted direct vent gas furnace with louvered grilles along the top and bottom

Direct vent wall furnace · 37 inch

Empire 37" DV35SG Direct-Vent Millivolt with Wall Thermostat Wall Furnace

  • Direct vent wall furnace, 35,000 Btu/h, natural gas or propane
  • Millivolt: heats without house power; wall thermostat in the box
  • Outside wall 4 1/2 to 13 in deep (19 in with kit)
View product

Our catalog calls the tall DVC and FAW models counterflow wall furnaces; Empire calls them fan type furnaces. A built-in blower pushes warm air out near the floor, which suits a bigger room you want evenly warm. The catch: the fan needs a household outlet.

Tall, narrow beige direct vent counterflow wall furnace with grilles near the top and bottom

Fan-type direct vent furnace · 72 inch

Empire 72" DVC35IPX Intermittent Pilot Direct-Vent Counterflow Wall Furnace

  • Fan-type direct vent furnace, 35,000 Btu/h, 275 cfm blower
  • Needs a 120 V outlet; pilot lights itself on each call for heat
  • Narrow cabinet fits between 16 in on-center studs
View product

B-vent wall furnaces (GWT and FAW)

A B-vent wall furnace needs no outside wall, only a route for its vent pipe up through the ceiling and roof. The Empire 66" GWTH25/35W B-Vent Gravity Wall Furnace recesses into a standard 2x4 stud wall and vents through 4-inch oval Type B pipe, which must rise at least 6 feet above the furnace.

The GWT belongs near the center of the space it heats, so warm air drifts through doorways to the next rooms, and never in a closet, alcove or small hallway a door could close off. On flat roofs a cold vent pipe can delay venting and trip the safety switch, so an insulated vent enclosure is recommended for the GWT there.

The gravity GWT runs on a self-generating millivolt system, no house power needed; the fan-type FAW models need 120 volts.

Vented room heaters (RH)

A vented room heater stands in the room like a console, its flue pipe running to a lined chimney or a B-vent through the roof. The chimney for an RH heater must be lined and sized properly, so line an unlined one first. No alcoves, no closets. With a hand-lit pilot and a dial thermostat on the gas control, it needs no outlet unless you add a blower.

Vent-free heaters: blue flame vs infrared

A blue flame heater warms the room air, which then circulates. An infrared heater's ceramic plaques glow and radiate heat straight to the people and objects in front of them. Both are supplemental room heat only.

Empire's blue flame heaters (BF models in our catalog) suit a closed room you want evenly warm, like an evening den. Infrared fits a spot where you sit or work facing the heater: you feel its heat before the room air warms.

The thermostats differ too. The BF-20 modulates from 8,500 to 20,000 Btu/h on propane (up to 18,000 at HI on natural gas); the SR-18T infrared model cycles its burner on at full input, then off. For quick warmth at a chair, the Empire 18" Hydraulic Thermostat, White 18,000 Btu, Vent-Free Infrared Heater is the radiant option.

What they share:

  • An oxygen depletion sensor pilot. It shuts the heater off if the room runs short of fresh air. Don't relight it until you provide fresh air, and have it serviced if it keeps shutting off.
  • No electricity needed. On sizes that take one, a blower is optional, and unplugging it doesn't stop the heater.
  • One gas for life. Each is built for natural gas or propane, and field conversion isn't permitted.
White wall-mounted vent-free gas heater with blue flames visible behind the front screen

Vent-free blue flame heater · 18 inch

Empire 18" Modulating Hydraulic Thermostat, White 20,000 BTU Vent-Free BlueFlame Heater

  • Vent-free blue flame heater, up to 20,000 Btu/h on propane, 18,000 on natural gas
  • Modulating thermostat; runs with no electricity
  • Needs a room of at least 1,000 cu ft; not for bedrooms or bathrooms
View product

Moisture, soot and foggy windows

Every vent-free heater adds water to the room: about 1 ounce per 1,000 Btu/h of input, every hour. A 20,000 Btu/h heater on high adds roughly 20 ounces an hour, a little more than a pint. In most supplemental-heat use, that's not a problem and adds welcome humidity to dry winter air; if humidity climbs, size the heater properly and use a dehumidifier.

In a tight or humid house, that moisture condenses on cold glass and fogs the windows.

A dark film on the heater or walls is soot: the burner draws in dust, pet hair and candle or tobacco smoke. The fixes: no scented candles or air fresheners while it runs, no fan blowing at it, and a dealer cleaning every year before the heating season.

How big a room a vent-free heater needs

A vent-free heater needs at least 50 cubic feet of room volume for every 1,000 Btu/h of input, counting every gas appliance that draws air from that space. A room that passes is an "unconfined space"; a smaller one needs extra combustion air brought in to the National Fuel Gas Code, which is your installer's call.

Heater input Minimum room volume Floor area at an 8 ft ceiling
10,000 Btu/h 500 cu ft about 63 sq ft
18,000 Btu/h 900 cu ft about 113 sq ft
20,000 Btu/h 1,000 cu ft 125 sq ft
30,000 Btu/h 1,500 cu ft about 188 sq ft
Our arithmetic from the 50 cu ft per 1,000 Btu/h rule, rounded up. A higher ceiling lowers the floor area needed.

For example, the BF-20W needs 1,000 cubic feet, and a room 16 feet long, 8 feet wide and 8 feet high has 1,024, so it qualifies with no extra air. Measure length, width and ceiling height, multiply, and compare.

Room 16 by 8 by 8 feet holds 1,024 cubic feet, enough for a 20,000 Btu/h vent-free heater that needs 1,000
Length times width times height: the room has to beat the heater's minimum.

Bedrooms and bathrooms

Bedrooms and bathrooms have their own caps: no unvented room heater over 10,000 Btu/h in either, and none over 6,000 Btu/h in a bathroom. In a bedroom, the 10,000 Btu/h models must be wall-mounted, never on the floor stand, and the room must still pass the volume test.

The Empire 12" Hydraulic Thermostat, White 10,000 Btu, Vent-Free Infrared Heater is one example: wall-mounted, it can go in a bedroom of at least 500 cubic feet, never a bathroom. So is a 10,000 Btu/h heater fine for a back bedroom? A 10 by 8 foot room with an 8-foot ceiling holds 640 cubic feet, clearing the 500 needed. Local rules can still say no.

Where vent-free isn't allowed

Some places don't allow vent-free heaters. We don't sell vent-free gas appliances for installation in California, Minnesota, New York City or Canada, and Massachusetts allows them only with conditions, including none in bedrooms or bathrooms. Our vent-free sales policy has the details and recommends a carbon monoxide detector in every room with a gas appliance; your local building department has the final word.

What size wall heater do I need?

There's no honest Btu-per-square-foot shortcut for a wall furnace: a rule of thumb can't see your insulation, windows, ceiling height or winters. Have your installer calculate the room's heat loss (a Manual J-style load calculation) and pick the input from that.

The room-volume table above caps vent-free heater size; it doesn't measure how much heat the room needs.

What does decide size:

  • Size it for the room. A vent-free heater must be sized properly for the application, with enough combustion and circulation air.
  • Large or spread-out homes need more than one. Two or more GWT furnaces are recommended for them.
  • Altitude lowers the rating. Above 2,000 feet, input ratings are reduced by 4 percent for each 1,000 feet above sea level; your installer or gas company makes that change. At 5,000 feet that's 20 percent, so a 35,000 Btu/h furnace drops to 28,000 Btu/h input.
  • Vent-free above 4,500 feet is unreliable. Thin air can make the oxygen sensor shut the heater down even when the room air is fine.

Which heaters work in a power outage

Standing-pilot models with no electrical parts keep heating through an outage: the DV direct vent furnaces, GWT gravity furnaces, RH room heaters, and BF and SR vent-free heaters. The fan-type DVC and FAW furnaces plug into a 120-volt outlet, so count on them needing house power.

Chart: DV, GWT, RH, BF and SR heaters keep heating in a power outage; fan-type DVC and FAW furnaces need house power
Standing-pilot models heat through an outage; fan types need an outlet.

How each type gets its power:

  • Millivolt furnaces (DV, GWT). The pilot flame heats a thermopile that generates the small voltage the gas valve and wall thermostat need.
  • Vent-free and RH heaters. A hand-lit or piezo-lit standing pilot and a thermostat built into the gas control; nothing to plug in.
  • Fan-type furnaces (DVC, FAW). A built-in blower on a grounded 120-volt plug. The FAW-55 IPX's intermittent-pilot system shuts off in a power interruption and restarts when power returns.

Wall furnace installation basics

Plan on a qualified installer for any gas wall heater: installation and gas piping must be done by a qualified installer or service agency, and in Massachusetts by a licensed plumber or gas fitter.

Rules that come up on most jobs:

  • Garages. Burners and igniters sit at least 18 inches above the floor, protected from vehicles.
  • No closets or alcoves for the B-vent furnaces and the room heaters.
  • Fuel conversion. Vented models switch gas only with Empire's listed kit, fitted by a qualified agency; vent-free heaters can't be converted.
  • Not everything is in the box. The DV-210 and DV-215 and the GWT furnaces ship without a thermostat, blowers are optional, and walls over 13 inches need the extension kit.

Replacing an old wall heater

If your old heater is a gravity wall furnace in an inside stud wall, a B-vent model like the GWT is the closest swap: it recesses into a 14 1/2 by 66 1/8 inch opening between studs 16 inches on center. When an old vented heater comes out, the installer must check that the existing vent is still sized right for whatever stays connected.

Switching to direct vent puts the new furnace on an outside wall, which may not be where the old one was.

Reading Empire model numbers

Empire's model letters name the furnace type, and the number after them is usually the input in thousands of Btu/h (the DV-25 is 25,000, the FAW-40 40,000). The exception: the DV-210 and DV-215 are 10,000 and 15,000. Empire defines most letters but not all; here is what they mean:

  • DV: direct vent wall furnace.
  • DVC: fan type direct vent wall furnace.
  • FAW: fan type vented wall furnace, on a B-vent.
  • GWT: gravity vented wall furnace. The GWT-50 is a dual wall furnace that heats two rooms sharing a wall.
  • RH: vented room heater.
  • BF and SR: unvented (vent-free) room heaters; SR models use ceramic plaques.
  • SPP and IP: standing pilot and intermittent pilot.
  • NAT and LP: natural gas and propane versions.

Empire doesn't spell out SG, SGX, the trailing X in IPX and SPPX, or the W and T suffixes, so we won't guess. The inch figure at the start of our product titles is the cabinet's nominal size: the DV35SG is a 37-inch unit, the DVC35IPX a 72-inch one.

Common questions

Do I need a plumber to hook up a propane wall heater?

You need a qualified installer, and in Massachusetts a licensed plumber or gas fitter. Installation and gas piping must be done by one, and the warranty assumes one. The propane tank and regulator come from your propane supplier; we don't sell them.

Does a direct vent wall furnace need electricity?

That depends on the model. The millivolt DV models run without house power; the fan-type DVC models need a 120-volt outlet for their blower. Look for "millivolt" or "fan type" in the title or manual.

Can a vent-free heater be my main heat?

No. An unvented room heater is supplemental heat for a room, never the primary heat source for a house. For daily heat, choose a vented wall furnace.

Why does my vent-free heater smell?

If it smells like gas: don't light any appliance, don't touch electrical switches or use any phone in the building, leave the building right away, and call your gas supplier from a neighbor's phone. If you can't reach them, call the fire department. Dust, pet hair and candle or tobacco smoke drawn into the burner cause soot, so skip scented products while it runs and have your dealer clean it yearly.

This guide was researched and drafted with AI assistance, checked line by line against manufacturer specifications and our catalog, and approved by the HearthDepot Hearth Team. Read how we write our guides.

Search

Call 888-398-1887Mon–Sat 8am–8pm ET
>